I hope the new album although as brutal and heavy as I hope it will be, will have some sort of melody. I'm hoping something to the likes of Aenema, Hooker with a Penis, etc. Actually blair mentioned that Danny was pleased about the vocal arrangement of a new song they laid out that day with Maynard, hopefully it will have some of that. I'm not asking something that I can hum too in a pop way. I remember the first time I put on undertow, sober had that universal sound that just reminded me that it wasn't the first time I had heard that song. Oh boy would I kill for that feeling again.

I don't know how to put it into words............ah forget it

you wanna bet?

ok let me give you an example.....look at meshuggah's music..........there isn't one song they made that has a melody..it's just a barrage of loud noise that gives me convulsions.

maybe I'm deaf..........but ain't ever heard their song to have a melody be it in thier music or vocals........another example is mike patton's side projects......although I respect him very much.....some of his music is so experimental that there is no melody at all...just noises.sound effects and the such.

but my definition of melody is something that rhymes and sticks to your head.you know........a particular chorus or a riff..etc.

Mr. Bungle definitely has tons of melody in it. Odd noises, sound effects, yes, but also melody.

seriously man, listen to some noise artists like merzbow. people get caught up in melody and forget that there are plenty of other elements to a song. music is just structured sound.

you just have to try to dissect the style. there are countless ideas and concepts to cover in terms of sound, and not everything must be gentle. even so, there is plenty of ambient music that's very mellow without holding a sense of true melody [such as lustmord or tim hecker]. it's a difficult adjustment to make, but there is very much structure and song-writing with these particular songs than there are in any other songs, it's just less noticeable and buried.

because Lustmord kicks ass :)

I'm trying to prove this wrong. It's difficult.
See, a song is something with vocals. So that rules out Merzbow, or Pan Sonic, and it rules out ambient works by the likes of Brian Eno and Experimental Audio Research (all of whom have tracks without melody).
Fenensz' last album had a track with vocals by David Sylvian. It's all ambient-noise but it DOES have a melody.. A vocal melody.
I'm guessing spoken-word doesn't count...
Wait! I've got it! Most tracks by early Einsturzende Neubauten! They have plenty of rhythm, but no melody... But they have singing! Just.. Atonal, unmelodic singing! So technically, they're songs...
Most of the tracks on Zeichnungen des Patienten O.T. are good examples.
Why wouldn't you? Why do you want us to answer that question for you - it's not something that CAN be answered, noise is like any other genre, it either appeals to you or it doesn't...
Do you like the intro to Stinkfist? That instrumental section of jimmy right after, "I am wide awake and heading home"? The intro to Third Eye Live (along with various other noise-sections of that song)? What about Faaip De Oiad*, that kicks ass, right?
If you do, at least some noise might appeal to you (the most accessable being Pan Sonic's Kesto or the aforementioned Einsturzende Neubauten.. And maybe Super AE by the Boredoms).
Too bad he's ambient.

As for this melody thing.. I think Tool illustrate Champion's point (that there is more to music than melody) brilliantly: Tool's melodies aren't particularly original or striking - it's the general SOUND and ATMOSPHRE of the band that appeals to most. Adam Jones and his guitar tones, for example, and that tribal drumming sound... Tool are expressive, but not just melodically expressive. A lot of their songs would suck if they weren't delivered in the exact way that they are.

*Actually my favourite track on Lateralus. No joke.

I think what your saying is you want some catchy hooks, and I agree. Yes, almost everything, if not everything, has melody, but in many cases it is instantly forgettable or completely unrecognisable. Tool songs have always had catchy melodies, and I would put my life on it they wont disregard this.

he was being sarcastic.

This thread is such a headache.
music= organization of sound. THere are 8 aspects to music such as melody, rhythm, texture, volume (i'd have to look in my music theory textbook for the rest).

All music has some combination these things whether intentional or not. A cacophony of jumbled noise still has rhythm. One note over and over is still a melody

Melody= notes in succession

Even if a song seems as random as a clownshoe in church it still has melody

I don't know why, but this is funny.

The definintion for melody I 've found is, 'the pleasing succession or arrangement of sounds'.

Music doesn't have to have melody. It appears melody is subjective.

I think 'melody' is something people have made up to put meaning to sound.

We make up everything to give it all meaning. The constant I've found while researching melody is 'pleasing' and 'succession of notes'.

^Wherever you researched that its bullshit. Since when did melody become something that has to 'please' us.

One location.

Hah thats funny. I think that definition stinks.

It might stink but I didn't make it up.

Well, why don't you re-write the dictionary and 'please' yourself.

Heh, I just found that a bad definition thats all, re-writing the dictionary would mean I cant use my time making bullshit posts on here.

go on, rewrite the dictionary.

Which would please me.

I dont want to show the guys up anyway.

Those Oxford guys?

Well, naturally.