View Single Post
scar's Avatar scar
05-06-2006, 01:26 PM
Reply With Quote

Quote:
Originally Posted by kabir
look here's the big problem.

as it is now, we have -

damn my eyes IF they should compromise a fulcrum watching me divide me, THEN i might as well be gone.

that doesn't make a lick of sense. IF, THEN. there's no IF here that makes sense, esp cuz there's no verb or adverb before "divide me."

IF they should compromise [our fulcrum one to need] divide me
THEN i might as well be gone.

anyone have any thoughts about how this phrase could make sense grammatically?

kabir,
i seriously think people are reaching here, trying to find some kind of life-altering lyric that can somehow give us another peek into TOOL's (or at least Maynard's) view of God and religion. it sounds so simple to me. you are right about the cause/effect, if/then structure of the phrase, but that sentence starts AFTER:

"dim/damn my eyes if they should compromise a full-grown wanton need."
that completes that sentence. i then hear, clear as a bell:

"IF I need (in reference to the wanton need, just spoken)
THEN I might as well be gone."

i sincerely hope this helps.
__________________
OpiateUndertowAEnimaScarLateralusSalival10,000Days

Last edited by scar; 05-06-2006 at 07:27 PM..
Old 05-06-2006, 01:26 PM   #183
Level 6 - Very Deep Thinker
 
scar's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: north kansas city
Posts: 103
Bincount™: 0
Re: lyrics - official thread

Quote:
Originally Posted by kabir
look here's the big problem.

as it is now, we have -

damn my eyes IF they should compromise a fulcrum watching me divide me, THEN i might as well be gone.

that doesn't make a lick of sense. IF, THEN. there's no IF here that makes sense, esp cuz there's no verb or adverb before "divide me."

IF they should compromise [our fulcrum one to need] divide me
THEN i might as well be gone.

anyone have any thoughts about how this phrase could make sense grammatically?

kabir,
i seriously think people are reaching here, trying to find some kind of life-altering lyric that can somehow give us another peek into TOOL's (or at least Maynard's) view of God and religion. it sounds so simple to me. you are right about the cause/effect, if/then structure of the phrase, but that sentence starts AFTER:

"dim/damn my eyes if they should compromise a full-grown wanton need."
that completes that sentence. i then hear, clear as a bell:

"IF I need (in reference to the wanton need, just spoken)
THEN I might as well be gone."

i sincerely hope this helps.
__________________
OpiateUndertowAEnimaScarLateralusSalival10,000Days

Last edited by scar; 05-06-2006 at 07:27 PM..
OFFLINE |   Reply With Quote