Ah, forgot to add Eulogy to my wish list. If we're talking dream setlist, who cares how long/realistic kind of business (but still somewhat realistic, i.e. they can't just play everything), mine would be something like...

Third Eye
The Grudge
Stinkfist
Eulogy
H.
(ambient jam)
Forty Six & 2
EBA/The Patient
Schism
Parabol/Parabola
Lost Keys
Rosetta Stoned
(ambient jam)
Pushit
No Quarter (or something else that's older and play it before Pushit)
<Intermission>
Disposition/Reflection/Triad
Lateralus
Aenema